Monday, November 30, 2009

Eastern philosophy much?


~ The first chapter of Demian describes two worlds that can both be appreciated. One world is created with rules and guidelines by those in authority over young Emil Sinclair. It is the world in which everyone older and wiser wishes him to dwell. The essence of this world is light; simplicity. The other world is referred to as the dark world. It is a world that someone explores on purpose. Although Emil was secure within the shelter his parents had set over him, he pursued the dark world. The dark side appealed to him because of the sense of adventure he experienced. The dark side does not represent sin; it represents maturity, and exploring who you are, completely. We know that there is good in us, and common sense, and logic. However, there are also flaws, and things out of the ordinary. When Demian began to explore the dark side, he became less dependent on those authority figures in his life, and began to develop character. The light side is like the Shire. Bilbo would have been fine if he had stayed in his hobbit hole, and not explored the "outside world". Life would have gone on the same, just as it had previously. However, he had a desire for adventure. He explored, and found that there was so much more to learn and appreciate. The rest of the hobbits are ignorant and stupid, and much easier to deceive if they were ever to wander outside of the light. As the book goes on, Emil is unfortunately misleaded. The character Demian is clever and confident, but immature. His warped logic and perspective on the Bible was probably derived from his disheveled home life. Demian instills a thought process into Emil that is frightfully similar to Eastern philosophy. We see it first in the second chapter. Demian introduces mind reading. This idea is too bizarre to be scary. However, in the next chapter, Demian withdraws into himself in a meditative state, an Eastern religious practice. Meditation is reflecting on one's inner Self, to understand the ultimate Self, which is Brahma. In chapter 4, after Emil leaves his home, he says, 'I was only concerned with listening to myself, with hearing the streams, the forbidden, dark streams that resounded within me beneath the surface'. This is the opposite of Christ likeness, where we are to love others and become selfless. Also, after painting the picture of Demian, he says, 'I felt recognition, rediscovery, knowledge, growing nearer and nearer in me'. His thought process has mutated drastically throughout the book already, toward Eastern philosophy. Despite the fact that Demian is intelligent, handsome, and confident, I blame him for perverting the sweet and innocent Emil Sinclair. The same thing happened to the poor boy in 'The Reader'.

~This is Emil Sinclair

3 comments:

Amanda on December 1, 2009 at 1:03 PM said...

I agree with what you're saying Sarah, but I think that emil's obsession with Demian is because he thinks that Demian holds the key to his identity when his parents "lost" it when he chose to lie about what he had done. I'm pretty sure that all of us know how purposeless Emil is.

Cameron on December 1, 2009 at 3:26 PM said...

This is great Sarah. I saw it right away, and I really like that you said that Emil didn't like it. It also says that he gets used to it. He tolerates and is decieved by it. When reading this I was disturbed had a very strange feeling, perhaps you did too. It was not that I simply disagreed, it was an unrest in my spirit. Spiritually, this began to trouble me. Have you taken a peak on the "other suggested reading" section? All three are about Eastern philosophy and Hinduism. We're stuck on it because we recognize it. The reason I think this book is so dangerous is because of the many readers that would and will agree with Demian and Hesse without any outside knowledge. I found it strongly, STRONGLY helps that you pray before you read and some times in the text for wisdom and to not be decieved. Remember, it does not at any point say that Emil was decieved. That is OUR conclusion and that is very important to note. Hesse doesn't feel that his character, who is most definitely a reflection of himself, was decieved. Rather, he unlocked a grand new knowledge. That is also why I believe he is obsessed with Demian because he impowers him with a new "knowledge" and gives him new reasons to rebel and also a said justification to do it.

Janine on December 2, 2009 at 7:21 PM said...

I strongly agree with what Sarah is saying in her post. If Emil had not ventured into the dark side he would still be a sheltered little kid, living under his parent's rules in a veil of innocence. I think that we all have been in our own dark side. Because of his happenings with Kromer and Demian he is now not as unkown to some of the other things beyond his house and the simple world he was living in before. This "dark world" requires more of Emil and I think that, in a way, he enjoys being challenged. At home all he had to do was read the bible and not get rough while playing with his sisters. This other world requires him to think and be independent. I'm not sure if Demian has necesarily poisened Emil. We all have someone in our lives who influenced us to grow up or be more mature. Maybe Demian is that person in Emil's life, only a lot creepier. (wrote this in class but put it on my blog which no one has)

Post a Comment

// QUOTES.

"Clever talk is absolutely worthless. All you do in the process is lose yourself."

-Max Demian

// lit seminar. // copyright 2009 - 2010. // all rights reserved.